Thursday, 13 November 2014

Oil dispute prompts East Timor PM to stay

By Matthew Pennington
  • From: AAP
  • September 26, 20144:47AM
  •  
    VETERAN East Timorese leader Xanana Gusmao says he's pushing back plans to stand down as the fledgling nation's prime minister as his fledgling nation continues to dispute oil revenues with Australia. 
      
    GUSMAO told The Associated Press in an interview on Thursday he'd intended to resign this September, but will now stay on until the first half of 2015, as East Timor grapples with disputes over oil revenues with Canberra and US energy giant ConocoPhillips.
    He said he remained committed to transferring leadership responsibilities to a younger generation, but declined to say who might succeed him.

    "If I suddenly leave without stabilising these issues it's like running away from your responsibility," Gusmao said ahead of his address on Thursday to the annual gathering of world leaders at the United Nations.

    The 68-year-old was a leader of East Timor's 24-year resistance against a brutal Indonesian military occupation that left more than 170,000 dead.

    He was elected the nation's first president after independence in 2002 and became prime minister in 2007.

    The half-island nation is struggling with high rates of poverty and meeting post-independence expectations, but Gusmao said he didn't believe there would be repeat of the unrest if the country's elite was unified.

    Ties with Australia have been strained by a legal dispute over a 2006 treaty that carves up revenue from oil and gas under the sea between the countries.

    "We are not desperate for more dollars, but it must be recognised that resources within our maritime borders are ours," Gusmao said.

    East Timor alleges Canberra spied in order to gain an advantage during the negotiations over the treaty.

    It has taken Australia to the United Nations' highest court in The Hague over the seizure of documents from a lawyer working for East Timor in the arbitration case.

    The two nations recently agreed to try to settle those differences outside the International Court of Justice, but Gusmao said if the negotiations did not yield a satisfactory response, East Timor would resume litigation.

    East Timor is also in arbitration proceedings with ConocoPhillips over what it alleges are unpaid tax revenues from the company's operations at a joint petroleum development area between Australia and East Timor.

    ASEAN observing possibility of Timor Leste`s membership: Indonesia`s envoy

    Rabu, 12 November 2014 18:43 WIB | 945 Views
     
     
    Nay Pyi Taw, Myanmar (ANTARA News) - The Association of the Southeast Asian Nations (ASEAN) members are studying the possibility of Timor Leste joining the organization, according to the Director General for ASEAN Affairs, Indonesian Foreign Ministry, Gusti Agung Wesaka Puja.

    Puja was speaking at an interview here on Wednesday on the sidelines of the preparations for the 25th ASEAN Summit in Nay Pyi Taw (November 12-13).

    He observed that the membership of Timor Leste had been a matter of debate among the ASEAN members. He added that each member state was studying Timor Lestes eligibility to join the ASEAN.

    "The process is still continuing," Puja noted.

    According to him, the ASEAN has been inviting representatives from Timor Leste to its Regional Forum every year as a measure to encourage that country to participate in discussions related to opportunities and challenges faced by countries in the Southeast Asian region.

    The ASEAN currently comprises ten member states, namely Indonesia, Malaysia, Brunei Darussalam, Singapore, Thailand, the Philippines, Cambodia, Laos, Myanmar, and Vietnam. ***1***

    Tuesday, 11 November 2014

    East Timor Belongs in Asean

    The country has made great strides fighting corruption and building democracy

    By
     
    In a year when the free world has faced growing threats on multiple fronts, one former problem geography actually sparks hope: East Timor. Although considered a backwater to all but the few analysts who track Southeast Asia and the Pacific, the prospects of this would-be member of the Association of Southeast Asian Nations could be brighter than many naysayers suggest—and matter more than they think. This should make the country’s prompt admission in Asean a no-brainer.

    Allowing Dili to join has been on Asean’s agenda for more than a decade. Delay was understandable amid violence and instability, but now East Timor is more democratic and politically stable than several longtime Asean members. Accession would also advance Asean’s role as a mechanism for collaboration—especially among smaller states at risk of being overwhelmed by China. East Timor can benefit from this dynamic while also making its own contribution.

    The doubters have some good points. For a period the country was the most unstable nation in the Pacific. Violence fanned by Indonesia swept the country as it moved toward independence in 1999, prompting Australia and other countries to intervene. The Timorese government in Dili requested Australian-led intervention again in 2006 when internal violence erupted. Much of the country’s infrastructure lay in ruins.

    Pessimists also point to questionable government spending, a voluntary leadership transition that now seems off track, and corruption and cronyism. Transparency International places East Timor at an undesirable 119th out of 177 in its primary ranking of countries based on perceptions of corruption. The country also has poor infrastructure and a 60% literacy rate.

    But there is good news, especially given major current and future gas production in the Timor Sea. Seeking to avoid the cycle of corruption and economic stagnation that has beset many poor countries with big energy assets, Dili established a Norwegian-style Petroleum Fund in 2005. This step ensures that some royalties are kept for future generations. In its first six years the fund grew to $8 billion. By June of this year it had reached $16.6 billion.

    Despite the history of corruption and instability, East Timor now possesses credible institutions of law and democracy. When Dili’s tax agency sought a higher assessment from ConocoPhillips , the country’s largest foreign operator, a local court actually ruled against the government—an unheard of outcome in many petro-states. Unfortunately, the government has since blamed and fired foreign legal advisors to the judicial system, but the original precedent now remains for various disputes in international arbitration. On the positive side, when the government passed a law earlier this year that restricted the press, the nation’s Court of Appeal struck it down as unconstitutional. Furthermore, current and former Western officials who have dealt with East Timor’s president and prime minister hold both in high regard for their stewardship—and their magnanimous rapprochement with former-occupier Indonesia.

    Some analysts have warned that gas production off East Timor may soon decline, leaving the country with mounting problems. But a major new field, Greater Sunrise, is expected to enter production this decade. The country’s agribusiness, especially coffee exports, is also prime for growth. Tourism is slowly developing, as memories of unrest fade and the country, which uses the U.S. dollar, becomes easier for travelers to reach.

    The success of East Timor is not purely an academic or humanitarian concern. There is no part of Asia or the Pacific that the Chinese government would not like to dominate, and East Timor is no exception. The country sits across a narrow sea from Darwin, Australia, which hosts an increasing U.S. military presence to counter China’s growing military capabilities and aggression. Beijing would no doubt like to use East Timor as a base and listening post if it could. In April, Chinese President Xi Jinping hosted East Timor’s prime minister, Xanana Gusmão, for an official visit, and they agreed to expanded—if vague—cooperation.

    East Timor is also geo-strategically important. The Pacific comes down to a few crucial chokepoints near Singapore, with the vast majority of Middle Eastern petroleum and other global trade with East Asia and the West Coast of North America passing through narrow straits like Malacca, Lombok and Sunda. All would be contested in the early stages of a conflict involving China, pushing trade farther south through the Timor Sea and nearby waters. This geographic reality is why major early battles in the Pacific War occurred in New Guinea, Guadalcanal and the Coral Sea.

    Put simply, free nations should recognize a good thing when they see it. Those who favor a civilized world order should want an East Timor that is improving and moving closer to the free world instead of China. Admitting Dili into Asean is a crucial step in this process—one that would give Timorese reformers an additional lever to use in their efforts to reduce corruption. It would also reward a small country that is playing a tough hand well.

    Mr. Whiton is the president of the Hamilton Foundation and the author of “Smart Power: Between Diplomacy and War.” He was a State Department senior advisor in the George W. Bush administration.

    Monday, 10 November 2014

    Xanana informou Passos sobre suspeitas de corrupção na justiça de Timor

     
     
     

    A double standard view of Timor-Leste - responding to Ted McDonnell’s article “Timor-Leste lawless state not worthy of ASEAN entry”

    *Cosme da Costa Araujo
     
    Ted McDonnell, a professional, independent, and expert on Timor-Leste wrote a piece last week argues that Timor-Leste is not worthy of ASEAN entry. In addition to other academics and analysts who label Timor-Leste with colorful name-callings, McDonnell comes up with a new creative nickname for Timor-Leste – a lawless state.
     
    He argues that by “sacking all foreign judges, introducing archaic media laws and detaining Mauk Moruk and his comrades”, Timor-Leste is a lawless state and therefore is not worthy of joining ASEAN. I find his argument similar to Susan Marx, Asia Foundation Country Representative, and Madhu Narasimha, whom Ramos Horta refers to as “an obscure and pseudo academic”.
     
    I have the privilege of reading many of the author’s articles on Timor-Leste and I find most, to be biased, unbalanced, opinionated, and subjective and interest, which not reflects the characteristic of a professional journalist. His articles do not represent the professional standards or at least Timor-Leste Journalist Code of Ethics (Arts. 1 &5) he aspires to abide by. Reporting and not confirming the other side of the story simply shows his unfitness for that profession.
     
    As in my response to Susan’s article two weeks ago, the issued resolution is within the boundary of the Constitution. The National Parliament acts within its constitutional power of making political decision. The issued resolution is a political decision to safeguard the national interest of the country. Dr. Benevides Correia Barros, spokesperson for Timor Lorosa’e Lawyer Association (TLLA), seconds the argument by stating “the State has constitutional power to safeguard the national interest of the country”.
     
    The resolution is simply the presentation of evidence by the Parliament for the Superior Council of the Magistrate (SCM) to consider and decide on of whether the Parliament’s call for the termination of the contracts of international judges and advisers is justifiable. The Parliament calls for the termination of judges’ contract because of national interest, force majeure, and the judges’ “inadequate technical capacity” and indications of “committing various incidents of judicial irregularities”.
     
    Days after the Parliament issued the resolution; the President of the High Court issued a communiqué urging all the judges to continue working, while waiting for decision from SCM. The SCM’s finally made its decision last week to terminate the contracts their contracts. I therefore see no interference from the Parliament with the competencies of the SCM.
     
    Pedro Bacelar Vasconselor, a renowned Portuguese constitutional lawyer who helped with the work of annotated Constitution, argues that, “it is legal to carry out an audit of the Timorese system including the suspension of contract of international judges”. He stated the issued resolution is “a small concern of a bigger issue that leaders of the country preoccupy with”. He later asserts that, “matters of national interest should not be decided by foreigners, but the Timorese”.
     
    According to Timor Lorosa’e Lawyer Association (TLLA), “the resolution is not in breach of the Constitution”. Dr. Benevides Correia Barros, spokesperson for TLLA, states that, “Timor-Leste adopts a relative, not absolute separation of power”. It is articulated in Article 69, which does not only talk about “separation of power” but also “interdependence” of sovereign bodies in exercising their powers. Therefore, he elaborates that, “under Article 118 (2), the Court is required, when exercising its function, to seek cooperation with other Sovereign Bodies, in particular to safeguard the national interest of the country”. He also argues that, “the resolution does not beach Article 121 (3), as it applies only to local, but not international judges”.
     
    Reading through his article, I find the author to be inconsistent, contradictory and at worst hypocrite. In one hand, he staunchly supports and fights for the respect of Constitution, separation of power, rule of law, and principles of democracy, but on the other hand, he supports Mauk Moruk and his revolutionary movement.
     
    I sympathize with Mauk Moruk’s revolutionary ideas (fight corruption and inefficiencies), but not the means he proposes to achieve them. Mauk Moruk calls for the abolition of the Constitution, dissolving democratically elected Parliament and Government, which are in essence against the Constitution, rule of law and principles of democracy. The Parliament issues a resolution to ban Mauk Moruk and his movement, which, they see posing a threat to the national security of this country. In the US, Mauk Moruk would have been charged and tried under “terrorist act”. McDonnell may be right and he knows better that Mauk Moruk initially comes with a good intention, but he may be hijacked, or “set up” and “manipulated” by foreign interest to destabilize this country.  
     
    A professional journalist with an objective, balanced, and independent view of Timor-Leste would the find the author’s calling of Timor-Leste “lawless state” is unjustifiable and at best prejudice.
     
    I also find the author’s argument that Timor-Leste is not worthy joining ASEAN to be inconsistent or to put nicely double standard. In one hand, he is so critical of Timor-Leste’s worthiness of joining ASEAN, while turning his blind eye on the developments in other countries like Thailand and Myanmar.
     
    If the author tries a bit harder to research on what is going on with other ASEAN member countries, he will find that in Thailand, new military dictatorship detained members of political class, shutdown media, dissolved the senate, in charge of government ministries and assumed total control of the country and much worse wait to come. In Vietnam, recently two blogger soon to be charged for violating Penal Code Article 258 on “abusing freedom and democracy to infringe upon the interest of the State”.  Bloggers were detained for posting essays that “had the potential to tarnish the state apparatus’ prestige”. In Myanmar, since the court denied and annulled an election won by Aun Sha Su Chi, the country is haunted by the omnipresence of military junta and as a consequence of that, all the democratic institutions and processes, which the author fights so hard for, are non-existent.
     
    If the author thinks Timor-Leste is not worthy of joining ASEAN, then my question is what makes these countries “worthier” to remain as members of the “respected Association”.
     
    If the author follows closely the development in the region, “the credibility of the respected Association” had long been tarnished with the Indonesian invasion of Timor-Leste, systematic and massive abuses of human rights, Myanmar’s court denial of Aun San Su Kyi victorious election, and the subsequent omnipresence of military dictatorship in Myanmar, and the military’s overthrowing of two democratically elected governments in Thailand. If the author believes that there is such a thing as “credible Association”, then the United Nations have no credibility for allowing country like North Korea to join and similarly the prestigious English speaking countries association – Commonwealth, for allowing country like Zimbabwe and then apartheid-South Africa to join.
     
    I also find the author’s remark of “PM Xanana’s anti-foreigner drive” is appalling. If the author had thoroughly done his research, he would find that the number of foreigners or “malae” working in the public institutions, not to mention private sector, had increased dramatically since PM Xanana come to office in 2007. In addition, Timor-Leste has every right to be befriend with Indonesian, that is what I hear experts call – pragmatism and real politic. It would be childish and naïve not to do so.
     
    The suspension of contract of foreign judges has nothing to do with anti-malae. They are found to be “technically incompetent” and “committed various judicial irregularities”. You would expect this to happen in any normal work-related contract, when an employee would be dismissed if he/she is not performing according to the contractual arrangement or causing detriment to the employer. An anti-foreigner sentiment would be like “putting asylum seekers in detention center”, “riots in Coronal beach”, and subsequent “assaults on Indians” and “the recent assault on Chinese expats in Vietnam”.
     
    Furthermore, leaders of this country including PM Xanana are elected not to appease any foreigners, but to serve the best interest of the Timorese people. I doubt the author, an outsider, knows better than PM Xanana, who sacrificed his whole life for this country, of what is the national interest of this country.
     
    If Lee Kwan Yew of Singapore, leaders of Communist Party of the People Republic of China and founding fathers of South Korea in earlier years listen to the lecture by pundits on about how to run their countries, they would not have become of what are they are today.
     
    To end, I would like to help the author with the lists of “criteria” for countries that fall under his famous term – lawless state.
     
    A lawless state should include also countries that unilaterally invade and help to invade other countries, spy on its citizen, leaders and citizen of other countries, put asylum seekers or “boat people” in detention center (even they themselves were originally “convicts” or migrants from other countries), withdraw from international court for fearing of a “fair dinkum” trial, ban Muslim women from wearing burka in public place, allow people to own gun and shoot at anyone for self-defense, charge its citizen for whistleblowing, prevent its citizen and confiscate their passports from testifying against the state, enact legislation that authorize indefinite detentions of immigrants, allow police to search telephone, email and financial records without a court order and a state proclaims to serve its people, but in fact serves only the interest of big corporations.
     
    With all these hypocrisies that happen in the world, one has no right to tell, lecture or even impose on others of what to do and not to do. Therefore, when I see a professional journalist calls for a regime change; it makes me doubt his credibility as a professional journalist and his fitness for that profession.

    Mari Alkatiri pede liderança unida para lutar contra ataques a Timor-Leste

    10 de Novembro de 2014, 09:14
     
     
    O ex-primeiro-ministro e secretário-geral da Frente Revolucionária do Timor-Leste Independente, Mari Alkatiri, apelou ontem à união da liderança do país para encontrar uma solução para as investidas que estão a ser feitas contra o Estado timorense, informou agência Lusa.  

    "Declaro que não permitirei que se continue a politizar uma questão processual e apelo a toda a liderança timorense para se unir na procura de solução para todas as investidas contra o nosso país", afirmou, numa mensagem divulgada na sua página na rede social Facebook.

    Na mensagem, Mari Alkatiri reafirma que não vai permitir que se "use um erro processual para se procurarem atingir a coesão nacional do Estado de Timor-Leste".

    "Todo o ataque que tem sido feito contra figuras da liderança faz-me lembrar a crise de 2006. Na altura o diabo era eu", salientou.


    O Governo de Timor-Leste ordenou segunda-feira a expulsão, no prazo de 48 horas, de oito funcionários judiciais, sete portugueses e um cabo-verdiano.

    No dia 24 de outubro, o parlamento timorense tinha aprovado uma resolução a determinar uma auditoria ao sistema judicial do país e a suspender os contratos com funcionários judiciais internacionais "invocando motivos de força maior e a necessidade de proteger de forma intransigente o interesse nacional".

    "Um parlamento irresponsável - Parlamento de Timor-Leste (de que sou membro) - adotou uma resolução de constitucionalidade duvidosa que acabou por politizar uma questão que podia ter sido fácil e corretamente tratada por via administrativa, técnica e legislativa", refere o antigo primeiro-ministro, sublinhando que era conhecido o mal-estar que se avolumava entre o Governo, tribunais e Ministério Público.

    Para Mari Alkatiri, "só por milagre" um país acabado de nascer "ficaria ileso de problemas desta natureza".

    "Em Timor-Leste também não é a primeira vez que isto acontece. Já durante a primeira legislatura o mesmo se verificou. Só que na altura o Governo optou por apoiar o sistema judiciário timorense a encontrar soluções no sentido de se introduzirem correções no sistema. E seria este o caminho certo que teria evitado a politização do assunto", acrescenta.

    @Lusa

    Friday, 7 November 2014

    Timor - o "estado" da Justiça

    31.10.2014
    Pedro Bacelar de Vasconcelos
     
     
    A Comunicação Social portuguesa destacava ontem o relatório divulgado pelo Banco Mundial (Doing Business 2015) que coloca Portugal em 25.º lugar num ranking de 189 países ordenados segundo um critério complexo que procura apurar a maior ou menor facilidade da concretização de negócios entre privados, nos vários países considerados ("Económico", 29 de outubro de 2014). Mais do que a posição ocupada, salienta-se a melhoria obtida relativamente ao ano anterior. Portugal teria subido seis lugares, colocando-se agora à frente de outros países europeus como a Holanda, Bélgica, França, Polónia e até, na Ásia, acima do Japão. Segundo declarações colhidas no Ministério da Economia, este sucesso relativo teria ficado a dever-se à flexibilização das leis do trabalho, à aceleração das decisões judiciais, à facilitação do registo de propriedades e ao cumprimento das obrigações fiscais.
     
    O mesmo relatório do Banco Mundial era também objeto de destaque em "Comunicado de Imprensa" do Conselho de Ministros de Timor-Leste. Embora colocado nesse ranking numa posição mais modesta, Timor-Leste é ali qualificado como a economia que mais progrediu na simplificação do processo de constituição de novas empresas (...) "através da conceção de um balcão único" - uma medida aprovada pelo Governo de Xanana Gusmão, em 2012 - "que reduziu o tempo necessário para abrir uma empresa, de 94 para apenas 10 dias". A simplificação administrativa e o melhoramento substancial do abastecimento da energia elétrica foram os fatores responsáveis pelo expressivo melhoramento do ambiente empresarial no território deste jovem parceiro da Comunidade dos Países de Língua Portuguesa.
     
    Em Timor, o fator mais adverso reside, por uma lado, na dificuldade de validação dos títulos de propriedade - herança da ocupação estrangeira e das deslocações forçadas de populações inteiras durante a guerra de resistência - mas também nas fragilidades de um sistema judicial criado a partir do zero, depois da libertação, com juízes recrutados de emergência e amplo recurso à cooperação internacional, sobretudo, a magistrados e assessores jurídicos de língua portuguesa. Contudo, a consolidação de um poder judicial independente e democrático, constituindo um fator estimulante do dinamismo económico, é, acima de tudo, uma parte essencial da própria construção do Estado soberano. Numa atitude discrepante com a atenção e o interesse que as velhas potências coloniais europeias costumam dedicar aos povos que oprimiram e exploraram no passado, em Portugal, nem se valoriza os sucessos que alcançaram nem os problemas com que se confrontam.
     
    De facto, os progressos significativos alcançados pelos timorenses na área da economia não transpareceram nos órgãos de Comunicação Social portugueses, nem a determinação expressa numa resolução aprovada no Parlamento Nacional em Díli, na passada sexta-feira, no sentido de um renovado empenhamento na consolidação da autonomia e da eficiência dos tribunais nacionais, obteve a atenção que indiscutivelmente merece. Uma indiferença incompreensível porque a Justiça é um setor fundamental onde a cooperação portuguesa se pode orgulhar da valiosa contribuição de inúmeros magistrados e assessores jurídicos. Contudo, a perpetuação da presença de funcionários internacionais, designadamente no exercício de funções jurisdicionais, a par dos juízes timorenses, é um fator de inevitável perturbação da transparência de um poder judicial independente que assume também relevantes atribuições jurídico-políticas, designadamente, em sede de controlo da constitucionalidade e da averiguação da responsabilidade criminal dos titulares de órgãos de soberania. Quando as multinacionais do petróleo procuram apoderar-se dos recursos naturais do povo timorense através de dezenas de processos instaurados nos tribunais de Timor, o mínimo que nos compete é esforço para compreender o que se passa e manifestar total solidariedade com o povo irmão e com os seus representantes legítimos!

    BARRIERS TO LONG-TERM FINANCING AT AFFORDABLE RATES: INTRODUCING A NATIONAL DEVELOPMENT BANK TO SUPPORT TIMOR-LESTE PRIVATE SECTOR DEVELOPMENT

    BARRIERS TO LONG-TERM FINANCING AT AFFORDABLE RATES: INTRODUCING A NATIONAL DEVELOPMENT BANK TO SUPPORT TIMOR-LESTE PRIVATE SECTOR DEVEL...